8 factors that show why the English Premier League may well be overhyped.
The English Premier League (EPL) is often touted as the best football league in the world, but does it truly live up to the hype?
While it boasts immense popularity and financial power, several factors suggest that it may not be as dominant as it is perceived, with several fans taking to social media to debate this factor after Liverpool got dumped out of the Champions League by a young and dynamic PSG in the Round of 16.
Here’s a closer look at 10 reasons why the Premier League might be overrated.
CAF president Patrice Motsepe has set high expectations for his fellow South African Benni McCarthy who was recently appointed Harambee Stars coach.
1. Style of Play: Very intense football, but what is the blueprint?
The Premier League is often praised for its high-intensity, end-to-end football.
However, this style sometimes sacrifices tactical discipline for entertainment. Unlike leagues such as La Liga or Serie A, where technical ability and structured play take precedence, the Premier League often rewards speed and physicality over tactical intelligence.
The result? A league that is exciting but not necessarily superior in terms of pure footballing quality. This explains why even in the England National Team set up, there is barely a recognised style of play, and the players produced are often limited in terms of technical ability.
For example, at the UEFA Euro 2024, England were often criticised for their lethargic displays, managing to get to the final quite by strokes of luck.
Declan Rice, valued at 105 million pounds, barely progressed the ball well from deep given his inability to break lines with his passing or even inability to play on the half-turn.The Spain squad had a plethora of talents that could do this job even on the bench.
)
Kenya has been dealt a blow in its ambitious multi-billion Talanta stadium project earmarked for AFCON 2027 with audit revealing millions lost.
2. A lack of competitiveness
One of the main selling points of the EPL is its unpredictability. On any given matchday, a lower-table team can upset a title contender.
However, this does not necessarily mean the league is the best in terms of quality. Many argue that the so-called “Big Six” struggle in Europe because they spend so much energy competing domestically, whereas teams like Bayern Munich (Bundesliga) or PSG (Ligue 1) dominate their leagues and focus on continental success.
If you look deeper, Pep Guardiola has won six of the eight Premier League titles on offer in his time as Manchester City manager.
While City have struggled this season, Liverpool have taken the mantle, and lead Arsenal by a mammoth 15 points at the time of writing, showing the lack of competitiveness by other teams.
In La Liga, three different teams have already lifted the Premier League title over the last 5 years. In Serie A, four different teams have won in the last five years, and there is a possibility that a fifth different team -Atalanta – could win it this season.
)
Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy has recalled one forgotten deender who has been out of the team since 2021.
3. European Success: not as dominant as advertised
Despite its financial might, the Premier League does not consistently dominate European competitions.
While English clubs have won the UEFA Champions League and Europa League in recent years, they do not consistently outperform Spanish, German, or even Italian clubs.
La Liga, for example, has produced more Champions League and Europa League winners in the last two decades, showcasing its superiority in European football.
Real Madrid have won two Champions League titles in the last three years. Teams like Sevilla and Villareal have also shown their worth in the Europa League over the last five years.
)
Benni McCarthy names a 32-man Harambee Stars squad for crucial World Cup qualifiers against Gambia and Gabon, blending experience and youth.
4. Player Quality: Overpriced but not always the best
The Premier League attracts many world-class players, but it also has a reputation for overpaying for talent.
Clubs often spend exorbitant fees on players who struggle to justify their price tags. While stars like Erling Haaland and Mohamed Salah have thrived, others such as Jadon Sancho, Nicolas Pépé, and Romelu Lukaku have failed to live up to expectations. In contrast, leagues like La Liga and the Bundesliga often develop and nurture talent at a fraction of the cost.
5. Tactical innovation: playing catch-up to other leagues
The Premier League has historically been slow to adopt tactical innovations. Spain, Italy, and Germany have long been the breeding grounds for revolutionary footballing ideas, from tiki-taka to gegenpressing.
Many of the EPL’s tactical advancements have come from foreign coaches like Pep Guardiola, Jürgen Klopp, and Antonio Conte, rather than being homegrown. This suggests that while the league benefits from innovation, it does not necessarily lead it.
It also explains a lot that no English manager has ever managed to win a Premier League title.
)
Usain Bolt on why Asafa Powell was the only athlete who used to leave him sweating.
6. Financial strength
The Premier League is the richest league in the world, thanks to lucrative TV deals. However, this financial strength often leads to reckless spending rather than sustained success.
While clubs can afford to buy the best players, this does not always translate into quality football. In contrast, leagues with stricter financial regulations, such as the Bundesliga, focus more on sustainable growth and development.
7. Global influence & popularity: more about marketing than quality
There is no denying that the Premier League is the most-watched league in the world, but its global appeal is often driven by superior marketing rather than superior football.
The league’s branding, aggressive international expansion, and English-language advantage make it more accessible than other leagues. However, when it comes to technical and tactical quality, many argue that La Liga or Serie A offer a more sophisticated footballing product.
8. Youth development: falling behind other leagues
While the Premier League has recently improved its focus on youth development, it still lags behind countries like Spain, Germany, and France.
Many of the best English talents, such as Jude Bellingham have had to move abroad to develop.
In contrast, clubs like Barcelona, Borussia Dortmund, and Ajax have long been known for producing top-tier talents through their academies.