Benni McCarthy on his impactful Manchester United tenure with key insights on coaching, players, and football philosophy.
Nine months ago, South African football legend Benni McCarthy left his role at Manchester United as part of a backroom reshuffle following the conclusion of the 2023/24 season.
The former Bafana Bafana striker and Premier League icon spent two seasons on the Red Devils’ coaching staff, working under Erik ten Hag.
McCarthy played a crucial role in developing United’s attacking play, particularly aiding the growth of forwards like Marcus Rashford. However, his departure marked the end of an era for the club’s coaching setup.
Now, in March 2025, he has taken up a new challenge as the head coach of Harambee Stars in a move that has excited fans across the country.
Pulse Sports looks at seven memorable statements that define his tenure at Old Trafford.
How new Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy will manage to convince foreign-based players, including dual-citizens like Linton Maina & Djed Spence, to play for Harambee Stars.
1. Ten Hag’s incredible work ethic
“I can imagine how frustrating it is for Erik because he’s probably one of the hardest-working managers I’ve come across. His attention to detail, that man goes to sleep at 3am, 4am in the morning.” – The Sun.
McCarthy had immense respect for Erik ten Hag’s dedication and work ethic.
He often spoke about the Dutchman’s tireless efforts to improve the team, highlighting how much effort went into making United competitive again.
2. High standards in training
“When you’re there, you see the work that goes into training and how the players are. I …” – The Sun
The former Porto and Blackburn striker was always vocal about the intensity of United’s training sessions.
He witnessed firsthand how players pushed themselves daily, ensuring they were ready for high-pressure matches.
3. Man City’s dominance under Guardiola
“Under Pep Guardiola’s leadership, I think the structure that the club has is perfect. The players play for him; they know exactly what to do, and there’s no disruption. So, of course, Man City has to be everyone’s favourite.” – Briefly.co.za
)
AFC Leopards chairman Dan Shikanda has confirmed that the club officially submitted all the paperwork on Tuesday, 5th March 2025, to acquire the land in Kasarani supposed to be used for the building of its stadium.
Even as a United coach, McCarthy was honest about Manchester City’s dominance under Pep Guardiola.
He acknowledged their superior organization and consistency, which have made them the team to beat in English football.
4. United’s Champions League ambitions
“Maybe not title contenders yet, but I think [closer] to getting themselves into the top four again for Champions League football. They’ve got the squad of players to do so.” – Briefly.co.za, The Sun
McCarthy always believed United had the quality to return to the Champions League. His assessment reflected the club’s gradual improvement under ten Hag, even if they weren’t immediate title challengers.
5. Mentoring Marcus Rashford
“Benni has been great with me and all the forward lads. You have to remember that Benni is part of a full coaching system. Everyone plays their little role and for the forward lads, Benni is that extra bit on top that we need. His relationship with me is good. We speak a lot. We always analyzing the games.” – snl24.com
One of McCarthy’s biggest achievements at United was his work with Marcus Rashford. Under his guidance, Rashford had one of his best goal-scoring seasons.
)
New Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy will begin his Kenyan assignment with 2026 World Cup qualifiers this month but which players risk missing out?
Kenyan strikers like Michael Olunga will be hoping to benefit from the same expertise as McCarthy takes charge of the national team.
6. Praise from Bruno Fernandes
“He is a really funny person, he’s always positive, he has good energy in the dressing room and training ground. He was quality as a player and is quality as a manager because we do many drills from finishing, headers, many stuff that he was really doing when he was playing and it can help us score some goals.” – snl24.com
Bruno Fernandes, United’s captain, appreciated McCarthy’s positive influence. His presence in the dressing room and training ground was seen as uplifting, contributing to a strong team spirit. Harambee Stars players will be keen to experience McCarthy’s motivation firsthand.
7. Coaching philosophy and teamwork
“I thought we needed one on the staff who is specific and responsible for strikers, Benni is doing a good job. I think the staff has a good balance and we do it together, it’s not only about Benni McCarthy, all have specific jobs in our staff. There’s a good vibe, they challenge each other, it’s a total package, and it’s not about one person.” – snl24.com
McCarthy emphasized teamwork and shared responsibility among the coaching staff.
This belief in a collective approach will be crucial as he builds a new chapter with the Harambee Stars, ensuring that his coac